| Redwall Abbey: To mouse scale, so a mouse would be the size of a human in this setting. The abbey is surrounded by Mossflower Wood |
- Martin the Warrior
- Mossflower
- Mariel of Redwall
- The Bellmaker
- Salamandastron
- Redwall
- Mattimeo
- Rackety Tam
It has taken me ten weeks to read these eight books. I found them to be clever, but laborious--excessively detailed in all of the wrong places. Jacques wrote more of these books; I am thankful they were not on the list.
| Legendary Martin the Warrior |
All of the characters in the Redwall books are small mammals of the British woodlands. In the first book, a horse appears, but from then on no hoofstock appear. In two books cats are characters. Otherwise everyone is a squirrel, mouse, vole, mole, otter, badger, shrew, toad, rabbit, hare, fox, rat, and the above-mentioned wolverine. There are several kinds of birds. There is no chipmunk--is that an American animal? Also no skunks, although a skunk would be a formidable weapon. The wittle amuhmuls are just too cute, wearing little clothes and eating quaint foods.
| The evil rat Cluny the Scourge |
I was troubled by peculiarities of scale. If I stood next to Redwall Abbey, would it come up to, say, mid-thigh? Or is everything scaled up so that the mice people were really 5 feet tall and I could easily shake hands with them? How high were the trees of Mossflower Wood? They were not specified as tiny trees, yet the critters interacted with them as though they were scaled down oaks and maples and apple trees. Was there a human-sized world somewhere? What would happen if a human found Redwall Abbey? Finally, I had to just let go of anything related to scale, subsisting in a sort of logistical limbo. And, of course, I was overthinking everything because I was unengaged. I did not relate, so I tried to compute. And computing didn't work either!
| Badger--good |
| Fox--bad |
| The squirrel hero Rackety Tam |
Fate and seasons smile on all,Verses, poems, and songs were plentiful and pleasing in all of the books, although I started skipping them after awhile, just to get the pages to turn faster.
From sunrise to the dark nightfall,
This bounty from both earth and tree,
Was made to share, twixt you and me.
To Mother Nature let us say
Our thanks, for life and health this day.
| Redwall food is so well-detailed that you can cook it yourself at home! |
I was troubled by the utter lack of compassion of the Redwallians. They felt little or no regret at taking lives in battle. They were unable to relate to the bad guys, to even imagine walking in their shoes. The bad guys were pre-labelled, their fates inevitable. This is how you gear up cultures for war--dehumanize the other side (and in this book, no one is even human to begin with!).
In conclusion, if you like these books and they do something for you (or for the kids who read them), then I'm OK with that. I can see that they might assist in empowering the weak. But as an adult I found the Redwall series boring, simplistic, and slow. I don't particularly recommend them.
SIDEBAR: Is It Quest Literature?
The Redwall books have most of the elements of quest literature--untried heroes and heroines going off to discover gifts and dangers, fighting for the right, and maturing into true adult warriors. (All true adults are warriors, I assert.) But the absolute lack of tension in these books makes one hero journey after another meaningless. We know exactly how the book will end from the very beginning.For the hero journey/quest to succeed, the element of peril must be full and robust. There should be some fair chance of defeat (have you seen "Rise of the Planet of the Apes"?) (were you worried that Luke might go over to the dark side?) (what about when Frodo turns to Sam in the belly of Mount Doom and says "No, it's mine, my own"?--that's a hero in serious peril). The Redwall books resemble video games more than they do quest literature.