Search This Blog

Sunday, February 5, 2012

Ben-Hur, by Lew Wallace


This is the 1925 Ben-Hur.

Ben-Hur, by Lew Wallace (1880) is an odd duck of a book to be on my Eager Readers list, or so it seemed before I read it. But, it truly is a great story, told with currency and urgency and authenticity. I felt like I was right there with Ben-Hur in Jerusalem, in Antioch, in the stands at the chariot race. All in all, it was masterful story telling. And, it made no bones about being a Christian story, so it could be taken on its own terms. The book Ben-Hur is more concise than the movie, tighter, with less melodrama. Ben-Hur is much younger than the Heston portrayal. The main action is Ben-Hur’s vengeance and quest for his family. Everything is presented in that context.

Judah Ben-Hur is a young Jewish prince living in Jerusalem who is wrongly accused of an attack on a Roman official. His punishment is to row in the Roman galleys as a slave; his family and fortune are busted up. His childhood friend, Messala, is in league with the barely wounded procurator to steal everything the Ben-Hur family ever had. In a magnificent battle scene, Ben-Hur rescues a Roman general and is thereby rescued himself from slavery. He gains wealth and status from this adopted father.

Heston in Ben-Hur 1959, rowing in the galleys
Still, he cannot rest. He must find out what happened to his mother and sister. This quest ennobles Ben-Hur and is a story arc equal to and as important as Ben-Hur’s connection with “the Nazarene,” as they call the imminent Christ.

The story of Jesus is the second story arc. The reader travels with the Wise Men as they find and worship the Christ child. The two arcs are parallel—finding Jesus is sort of like finding your lost family, in the terms of this book; both are ways to find that elusive ideal called Home. And the one journey being concrete while the other is spiritual works very nicely. Ben-Hur and the remaining wise man (Balthasar) are present at the crucifixion, during which Ben-Hur is profoundly changed (and Balthasar is taken directly into heaven with Jesus). This transformation then enables Ben-Hur's earthly happiness, as it makes him acceptable to his childhood love, Miriam. The teachings of Jesus also erase the class differences between them and they are portrayed as living "happily ever after."

The portrayal of the Jewish struggle against Roman domination is a primary theme. Ben-Hur and his friends want a worldly king with armies and power. The desire to overthrow Rome is noble and necessary. They are courageous in their fight for freedom. But the Jews are also presented as having Jesus’s blood on them—they betrayed him to the Romans when he wasn’t the earthly king they wanted. Wallace curses all Jews for all time for betraying Jesus, an accusation that I do not find justified.

The book is a good read, interesting, engaging. Several sequences are riveting—the battle scene during which Ben-Hur escapes the galleys, the chariot race, the transformation of Ben-Hur’s mother and sister. I held my breath through the chariot race, even though I knew exactly how it turned out. I was impressed by how detailed it was—I really felt like I was there. And I wept with Mother and Tirzah as they were healed.

The 1959 film never showed Jesus' face--you
came to know him by the expression on Ben-
Hur's face--a wonderful film-making decision.
And, the story of Jesus is much stronger when seen through the eyes of Ben-Hur than it is when presented directly. Ben-Hur filters it and represents us in skepticism, wonder, and, finally, faith. What a masterful idea Wallace had to write the book in this way.


So, this book was great stuff. I remember liking it when I read it decades ago. And it has held up well. It’s a story of adventure, revenge, redemption, and love. And, it’s a story about an adult emerging from the turmoil of of a child's point of view. I highly recommend it.


Sidebar: Ben-Hur and the Hero Journey

This diagram is based on the work of Joseph Campbell.
If you've followed my blog, you know that tracing the role of the hero quest in the literature I'm reading is an underlying theme. I watch out for it because it is specified by Joseph Campbell (one of my personal heroes) as found in the stories and literature of almost every culture. How does a person grow up? The hero quest stories present the journey for us, demonstrating the pitfalls, dangers, diversions, and the great rewards of taking the path to enlightenment/full adulthood. Ben-Hur loses himself--his name and home are stripped from  him. He doesn't even own himself, as a galley slave. The book presents his struggle to find himself--by finding his courage, his cause, his family, his salvation. He acquires tools and gifts that he uses to complete his quest. What video game could want more? Christian game designers, what are you waiting for? This hero journey is ripe for the picking.

Sidebar: Lew Wallace

I love this quote by Lew Wallace--it's my dream, too. I found it at http://thinkexist.com/quotes/lew_wallace/.

"I know what I should love to do--to build a study; to write, and to think of nothing else. I want to bury myself in a den of books. I want to saturate myself with the elements of which they are made, and breathe their atmosphere until I am of it. Not a bookworm, being which is to give off no utterances; but a man in the world of writing--one with a pen that shall stop men to listen to it, whether they wish to or not."

The following link presents a brief history of Wallace's military career. He was a man of action as well as a writer. (I don't know why I don't think those things go together!): 


Friday, January 20, 2012

The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King, by J.R.R. Tolkien


Tolkien's Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King is the third book in the Lord of the Rings trilogy and the fourth of the books set in Middle Earth.

Once again, I was drawn into Middle Earth as if it were a real place, one that is now part of my personal and historical past. It is as compelling as Camelot or Shangri-la, and other "lost time" fantasies. And much more.

There is such a gritty reality to the Rings trilogy. Nothing is clean in this book--all are tainted by the bitter fumes of the dark lord. Light is fading in almost every regard: the sky is darkening; people move through foul caves and tunnels; people subsume their identities in disguises; in this book, all are moving toward the final war against the Eye. Frodo can no longer see the Shire, can no longer remember the taste of bread or the smell of new-mown grass in the fields.

The lost city of Shangri-la
Frodo and Sam face gruesome, soul-wrenching ordeals as they stagger toward Mordor bearing the weight of the ring--Shelob the spider, orcs, the creature Gollum, Nazgul, heat,  starvation, molten rock, and the utter hopelessness of their quest. Pippen waits with Gandalf at the doomed city of Gondor, watching insanity spread as the enemy gathers its forces. Merry rides with the Rohirrim, but disguised and in secret with Eowyn, riding toward war and certain doom. All of his friends are fighting. He must fight for them. Aragorn, Gimli, and Legolas take the pathways of the dead…Aragorn’s faith in himself is tested; he is royal or he is dead. And, if the dead do not follow him, the war against evil is lost.


The most moving part of the book, to me, comes after the battle of Peleanor, when it is clear that the titanic battle that was a grueling victory for the West was a mere skirmish for the Eye. His forces are vast and he will defeat the good, if battle is the method of attack. The forces gather in council. Should they strengthen defenses and die in a few months, or ride out to the attack now and die quickly, Aragorn asks. In this state of hopelessness, the council decides to have faith in Frodo and Sam. If men will be wiped out, they will be wiped out creating a distraction that takes the Eye away from Frodo and the ring, which are secretly in Sauron's very stronghold. Aragorn's men agree to sacrifice their own lives for the future of all. This is a decision of great beauty.


An image of Camelot
This book was full of fear and battle, wounding and battle. The way Tolkien sets up the victory at Pelannor and then snatches it away made the doom so much more real. I felt a glissando of sheer terror at that moment, horror and loss. And I felt all the more resolute when Aragorn led his army into action and into certain death. I was right with them.


Yes, the Rings books are more in the endless procession of guy-bonding books that so fill the fantasy and science fiction genre. In this book, Eowyn is the only woman who has any role whatsoever--but her character is fully developed--more so even than in the movie. She channels her heartbreak over Aragorn’s dismissal of her love into valor. And her role is essential to the victory—her killing of King Angmar of the Dark Riders is marvelous symbolism and drama. And then she gets a wonderful gentle romance with Faramir in the Houses of Healing. I loved that. She must come into her true power before love can enter her life.

Middle Earth
But the Halflings are the true heroes of the story. Their courage, loyalty, wit, and charm are terrific. They are more fully developed for me now that I have such a familiarity with both the movies and books. They show that danger, fear, hunger (and the unknown in general) only strengthen the pure in heart. In fact, that is the hero journey for most of the principal characters--good and bad. How will you respond when the rug is jerked out from under your life, when the feces hits the fan, when you are truly and utterly lost? What will guide you through the dark? What is your light of Elendial? The characters of these books will show you many different strategies for coping. And they demonstrate courage over and over.


I had to include at least one photo of Viggo Mortensen as
Aragorn, the returned king of the title.
I highly recommend Tolkien for junior high school age and up. They are truly beautiful and rich. However, not everyone can read fantasy, so you don't "have" to read them and you don't "have" to see the movies. But, please, at least once, give them a try.

As soon as I finished reading the Tolkien titles on my list, I started reading books by Mark Twain. Switching over to Tom Sawyer has given me mental whiplash. I switched from the sound of ancient sagas being told by candlelight to Twain’s tall-tale-teller voice. I can almost hear him chuckling at his own wry jokes. Still, Tom Sawyer is also a quest story, and holds up well in that genre in its own way. Frodo bearing the ring and Tom bearing the pansy…hmmm.


There's some weird stuff out there. For sermons and essays on LOTR, try:
www.sermoncentral.com/sermons/the-lord-of-the-rings-sermon-series...

http://www.gradesaver.com/the-lord-of-the-rings-the-fellowship-of-the-ring/study-guide/

Saturday, January 14, 2012

Long Arm of Not the Law, Chapter 5


Here is chapter 5 from the book I am writing, called Long Arm of Not the Law. It's long enough now that I can't read through the whole manuscript before I start working on a new chapter. Please excuse this detour from book reviews. Long Arm is about a series of deaths that are considered to be accidents. However, a pattern begins to emerge. Maybe the deaths are not accidents.


CHAPTER 5 THE EMT


This is a book of funerals mainly because of a group of particular deaths—deaths by accident, injury, illness, deaths by surprise. Sometimes you look at the daily details of things and you can’t see patterns. But if you pull way, way back, something interesting may emerge. When you stand by a river, you see width and depth, but when you look at images from a satellite, you can see that your spot on the river is part of an extensive network of related and linked creeks and streams and rivers. Betty Brand was the type of person who would pull way back, would turn off emotional and social filters and just see what’s there. Betty Brand started to see a pattern, started to collect deaths. This book is the story of the deaths she collected and how she made sense of them.


The next death in Betty’s collection was emergency medical technician (EMT) Julia Berne. Julia was rumored to be a lesbian, but because her mom had been so respected in the community in the 1970s, and because she was exceedingly discreet, no one ever said anything out loud about it. Julia’s mother Audrey Willard Berne had been inducted into the Ohio Women’s Hall of Fame for her work on local history, her book on the history of public health in Ohio, and her Statistical Manual of Outbreaks of Head Lice, which became a standard in health departments throughout the Midwest.


Maybe her mom’s quest to eradicate head lice gave Julia a “head” start in lesbianism, because it meant that her hair, although always nicely styled, was always also short, coiffed, never longer than about two inches, never hitting her shoulders in her whole childhood. Anyway, the haircuts probably didn’t contribute to Julia’s homosexuality, but made it easier to fly under the radar. Yes, I think you can be under the radar but also out of the closet. Actually, most straight people are under the radar. They don’t go around talking about sexual predilections and neither did Julia. As far as the community liked to believe, Julia was totally celibate.


Julia worked regular shifts on the Emergency Medical Squad. She reported to the EMS building at 6:00 every evening and worked till 2:00 a.m. Most nights, after she checked the “truck,” making sure it was well stocked, clean, and gassed up, she dozed or watched cable TV. Usually at least once per evening, she would have a walk-in. Bartie Immel’s common law wife brought him in every few weeks for a blood pressure check, sometimes because his fuse was too short, sometimes because he was so flat as to seem almost dead.


“Everything checks out OK, Bartie,” Julia said, wrapping the blood pressure tubing around the cuff. “One twenty-two over eighty-five. Like always.” She grasped his wrist and felt for his pulse.


“Like always, Lois,” Bartie said. “I tell you every time.” Lois rolled her eyes. “It was just that one time it was high, when I didn’t know what I was drinking. I thought it was beer.” It had been Red Bull.


Julia shushed him, watching the sweep second hand of her Bulova.


Every now and then, Bartie brought in Lois, usually for “sugar.”


“She don’t seem right,” he told Julia. “I think it’s her sugar.”


Lois did a good job managing her “sugar,” but Bartie was easily alarmed. Julia rubbed down Lois’s finger with an alcohol wipe and pricked her with a test strip from the diabetes kit Lois had brought along. Her level was usually close to normal. However, adult onset (type II) diabetes was a scourge in Gerry County. Bartie’s dad lost his leg and then his life to the disease. Lois’s mom, too, had suffered from it, dying from congestive heart failure exacerbated by obesity. No wonder Bartie was nervous.


The carb-heavy diet of the poor was hypothesized to be a contributor to the high prevalence of diabetes—pizza, bread, potatoes, hamburger, bacon—cheap calories, but also deadly.  Fresh vegetables were probably the least-eaten food group in Maple Hills. When she first moved to Gerry County, Elaine Dixon had been amazed at the prevalence of what she called the “yellow-white” meal—chicken and noodles ladled over mashed potatoes, side of canned corn, yeast roll, and butter. Washing it all down with a glass of whole milk made the experience complete. Another version of yellow-white was pounded and breaded pork tenderloin (called “Gerry County Veal”) on a white bun with mayo and pickles and with French fries on the side, often glopped with melty yellowy cheese. This delectation was often consumed at the Eat-n-Time Dairy Bar, and accompanied with white (of course) ice cream.


Julia could gather the data, but she could not treat. All she could do was offer to transport if the data indicated a serious problem. She also changed dressings and checked bee stings (if the person who was stung made it all the way to the EMS building, that alone indicated a lack of anaphylactic shock). But every few nights, there was a transport, a car wreck, someone with chest pains, a bad fall with a broken bone, or, worst of all, a beating or gunshot wound. Julia and her shift partner received a page similar to the one Cody Miller got, swung their gear into the cab of the ambulance (or “squad” as it was more commonly referred to) and took off with the siren blaring and the lights flashing. Julia had trained herself not to react. Just don’t react, she repeated over and over through the years until it became a part of her, something she took to every injury scene.


One evening, on Route 17 North not far from where Police Chief Duncan Smith had crashed, Julia and her partner pulled up to a grisly scene. A Ford Explorer was off the road—far enough off that it had probably rolled a few times. One tire was blown. Julia could see a body out among the broken corn stalks; she could see that it was not in a normal posture for a living human. It was her job to walk on out there, through the stubble of this season’s harvest, keeping between the rows, watching the shiny black tops of her steel-toed boots, seeing the boots advance, seeing her medical box lower onto the soil. Just don’t react, she said to herself.


It was a white female, or had been. Julia bent over the still warm form, placed her fingers on the neck, on the carotid, the former carotid. Nothing. She gently turned the shoulders to lift the body. She unsnapped the lid of the med box, extracted the stethoscope. Cradling the woman’s chest against her own, she pulled up the shirt to put the stethoscope against the flesh of the back. No breath sounds. Nothing. She moved the woman onto her back. The head fell loosely to the side. Just don’t react. In the Explorer, children were screaming. Just don’t react. She closed the eyes and shook out a folded up yellow poncho from its tiny carry bag. She placed the poncho over the body. It was just a body now. She knew the woman though. She had recognized the Explorer right from the start.


A few months later, Bartie brought Lois in, toting along her insulin kit as usual. Julia looked for a long time at the insulin. “This stuff is expired, Lois. I’m going to confiscate it.”


In the morning, Julia was found dead, a syringe in her hand, an empty vial of insulin at her side. It was the accident, that’s what the EMS director said. It was all the accidents. She never cried. She should have cried.


Carl Wallingford was sympathetic, introducing many Maple Hills residents to the illness called post-traumatic stress disorder. He could discuss its signs and symptoms in detail. He knew Julia. She had transported him once after a storm when he had fallen and broken his leg trying to move a downed tree in the street next to his house. He hadn’t seen and wasn’t injured by the live power line under the tree, but that was all Julia could talk about as the ambulance hurtled toward the hospital. Accidental death.


And now she was dead. Her funeral was not ritualized—an EMT didn’t rank with a police chief or a young fire fighter—and Julia had always been private. Still, the uniformed members of the squad kept guard over Julia’s body, rotating every two hours. The visiting hours and services were held at the local funeral home, where Julia’s mom and dad received mourners, hugs, tears, shared memories. During the services, conducted by a woman minister from the city, a stranger sat with Julia’s mother, a stocky woman who kept her head down. Tears dropped into her lap. She was listed in the obituary as a “special friend.” She would miss Julia in a way none of the others would ever understand.

Welcome, Worldwide Readers

New year's resolution: to have blog hits by at least 25 different countries before January 1, 2013.


My thanks to all who have read my blog, but a special thanks to readers from outside the United States. I am gratified that you want to read an entry on this blog written by a rich (in world terms) white woman from (in world terms) the middle of nowhere . I see you, Russia, Romania, India, Taiwan Thailand, and especially Peru. South America is sort of a forgotten continent in the U.S., but not to me.


Next post: A chapter from the book I am trying to write, called The Long Arm of Not the Law.

Thursday, January 5, 2012

The Adventures of Tintin, by Herge


The Adventures of Tintin follow the life and times of Belgian boy-reporter Tintin, whose profession throws him in the path of of one fantastical adventure after another. He hangs out with his wonderfully-drawn dog Snowy, his friend Captain Haddock, who struggles with his sobriety, and Professor Calculus, who is partially deaf. Lots of slapstick involves tripping, falling, hitting each other, misunderstood speech, and so on, on a Three Stooges sort of level.

Here's a typical page from the graphic novels.
The Tintin stories are comic books—bound in groups of three. Truly, they are graphic novels, each story running about 60 pages, combining words and color images. Often, the frames were so crammed with words that I wondered about the appropriateness of the graphic novel format--each square was more words than image. I also found it jarring to move from narrative reading to the graphic novel. I was so used to reading words only and had a hard time making myself take time for the pictures. (See sample page, left.)

Tintin's adventures are grand—saving sovereign nations, going to the moon, stopping pirates. The books have a geopolitical slant totally lacking in American children’s literature. The friends go all over the world—the third world, not Europe. The books were written in France—Europe is too much like staying home. Truly, the stories reflect a disdain for anything non-European and are scathing in their stereotypes of almost every ethnic group other than whites. You must leave many sensitivities at the door when you enter these books.

[Go to the website for Tintinologists at http://www.tintinologist.org/ to delve deeper into the Tintin world.]

The Opera Singer--she and her maid were the
only female characters in all the books I read.
The earlier books, in particular, are entirely politically incorrect. The stereotypes are quite ugly. Hergé seems to have a learning curve, though, as later books are more generous in assigning human characteristics to those other than whites. There is one female character in the whole series (well, she has a maid, so that makes two)—an opera singer who recurs. Otherwise, this is a totally male world. Totally. A comment on racism appears in this Wikipedia entry.
Following on from the success of Tintin in the Land of the Soviets (1929–30), Tintin in the Congo also proved popular with the Belgian public, allowing Hergé to continue the series with a third installment, Tintin in America (1931–32). The book was also hugely popular in the Congo, and retained its popularity there throughout the 20th century. Since the late 20th century, however, the book has came under criticism from some for its portrayal of the Congolese people, which several critics have called racist. The book has also been criticised for its portrayal of big game hunting and the mass slaughter of African wildlife. Hergé himself was embarrassed by the work because of these elements, for which he expressed regret in later life, referring to the book as an error of his youth. It is because of its controversial nature that its publication in English was delayed until 1991.
All analysis aside, the Tintin adventures have an amazing following among tween-age boys. My nephew Jake Shapiro said that he loved these books when he was younger—read them all over and over again. Others who have commented (via a Facebook query) share Jake’s international background—my sister, kid's lit aficionado Robin Dickerson, said that the books were extremely popular at the British School library where she worked for awhile when living in South America. Interesting.

I ended up liking these. Marvelous flights of fancy in exotic locations—and lots of fighting, guns, and mystery.The action rocks, the humor is moronic, one character is a dog. What more can you want? I wish I could find these books in full-size format. The squinched type and tiny drawings were a barrier to my enjoyment.

Movie Note
[For a great discussion of racism in the books and lack thereof in the movie, go to the article in the Atlantic on this very topic: http://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2011/12/how-spielberg-handles-the-racial-problems-of-the-tintin-books/250382/]

The Tintin books were on my children's reading list. When I read them I had no idea that a Tintin movie was in the works--much less that Peter Jackson would be involved with the production. As of this writing, I have not seen the movie, but the trailer looks gorgeous, fulfilling the visual potential in the graphic novels. I assume that the politically incorrect material will be eliminated or soft-soaped; I am more interested in the role of humor in the film. It was only by viewing the stories through a slapstick lens that I could enjoy these books. Without the humor, the books would not hold up. I wonder how the filmmakers balanced the adventure with the humor. Please feel free to comment on this blog or on my Facebook page. I'd especially like to hear from you if you have read the books and seen the movie.

[View one of the trailers at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=op3w_ICK4us]

Titles Read
I haven't yet been able to locate volumes 1 and 2 of The Adventures of Tintin (maybe because they have been withdrawn for inappropriate content??). Whoever has them checked out from Vinton County's Herbie Wescoat Library in Ohio, please return them! I read volume 3 (The Crab with the Golden Claws; The Shooting Star; and The Secret of The Unicorn); volume 4 (The Broken Ear, The Black Island, and King Ottokar's Sceptre); volume 5 (Land of Black Gold; Destination Moon; and Explorers on the Moon); volume 6 (The Calculus Affair; The Red Sea Sharks; and Tintin in Tibet); and volume 7 (The Castafiore Emerald; Flight 714; and Tintin and the Picaros).

Friday, December 30, 2011

Treasure Island, by Robert Louis Stevenson

Treasure Island. Pirates. Booty. Cutlasses. Danger. Double-crossing. That’s about all there is to say about Robert Louis Stevenson’s tale of adventure on the high seas. But, of course, being me, I can say much, much more. Last night I was at a restaurant waiting for Chinese food to arrive at my table. I started jotting down words called to mind by this book: fast, roller coaster (and rolling sea), terrifying (even when I already knew the ending), gruesome, dark. Treasure Island is a children’s book through and through, but it is a terribly dark vision, a sort of bleak, godless Narnia.

[Learn about Stevenson at http://www.online-literature.com/stevenson/ or at http://www.robert-louis-stevenson.org/.]

Long John Silver. From the book Treasure Island by R.L. Stevenson. Thomas Nelson & Sons edition c.1930. (1899-19992 / 902_05_1862943 © Universal Images Group)Young Jack Hawkins works and lives at his parents’ inn. He becomes involved with pirates when a mysterious guest comes to stay--to hide there. Eventually, Jack becomes the owner of a treasure map--a map of Treasure Island. Only a few other people know about the map and the island, but each of them wants that map pretty bad. Jack works through the unfailingly honorable Doctor and Squire (although the squire is a bit gullible) and comes to set sail on the Hispaniola with his friends and the motley crew (surely this is the original motley crew). I’m not going to give away too much of the plot here. Go get the book. It’s a quick read, so read it--and read it aloud to anyone between 8 and 13 years old.

Jack Sparrow.jpgThe pace of the book is masterful--in a sense, tidal. Huge waves of action come inexorably at you and then ebb away not to disappear but to gather strength for another assault of the beach. Prior to the sea journey, the pirates appear just one, briefly, then another, then two or three, like an ongoing tide themselves until the book and the Hispaniola’s honest crew are totally swamped with pirates. This breath-catching pace was aided and abetted by Stevenson’s able use of foreshadowing. A character expressed and then dismissed a doubt. Another character was just a bit off the norm. A name was dropped, a feature was mentioned. The sense of danger and doom coming in wave after wave began on about page 1 and ended on about page 296 (of 298). No let up.

Stevenson also draws characters and creates images that are striking and original. Ben Gunn, ghostly and odd. The ship marooned up a river and laying on its side. Guns sticking into the portals of the tiny fort. Dead bodies lying on a blood-drenched deck. The star of the menagerie, though, is certainly the pirate captain Long John Silver. I don’t know the provenance of pirate characters, but surely all pirates since have borne a debt to Long John Silver. Shaggy-haired, peg-legged, parrot squawking on shoulder, and above all so two-faced that he almost has no face at all--he’s elusive in all of his outrageousness. Johnny Depp’s Jack Sparrow is the best portrayal of Long John Silver that I can imagine. He has that same unctuousness, slipperiness. However, Jack Sparrow does seem to develop loyalties. He has a side to be on. Not Long John Silver. He is ever and only on his own side.

I was intrigued by pirate images. Peter Pan’s Captain Hook seems to draw greatly from Stevenson’s character, except missing a hand instead of a leg. Depp’s Captain Sparrow seems to be a direct descendant. When anyone thinks of “pirate” they must surely envision some amalgamation of these three. Kidnapped is next on my reading list. What pirate will that book reveal? It struck me that the Hook/Silver pirate is sort of a personified dragon (or vice versa). The dragon symbolizes mindless greed, mindless amassing of whatever is the chosen item--but it is often treasure. There is no life of the heart. It is not a “feeling” life.

Only the mid-book switch of narrators is awkward in this book--it even makes for clunky chapter titles. All of a sudden two chapters are first-person narrated by the Doctor instead of by Jack Hawkins, who narrates the rest of the book. I wish Stevenson had found another answer to getting out the doctor’s experiences while Jack is absent. Otherwise, this book is rapidly excellent.

At least there are no token women in this book--no blonde-of-the-month for a perfunctory romance. Except for one scene, this book is all male. The non-token woman is Jack’s mother, who shows great bravery and determination early in the book. She is a warrior in defense of her inn and her boy. Romance can so muck up a good adventure story. Look what it does to Depp’s Jack Sparrow!

A high recommend for this book for children and adults both. Read it before your next Pirates of the Caribbean excursion and you won’t be sorry.

NOTE OF SCHIZOPHRENIA: How did the same man who wrote Treasure Island, Dr. Jeckyl & Mr. Hyde, and Kidnapped also write the insipid A Child’s Garden of Verses?

SIDE BAR: I am especially intrigued by Treasure Island now that I have begun writing one of my own. For example, at one point the idea of an apple barrel freely available to the ship’s crew is oddly introduced in a passage about the liberality of the owners. Turns out, the author needs someplace for Jack to hide to overhear the pirates’ plans. It is part of the god-like-ness of writing a fiction. A problem? Voila! An apple barrel. Writing a novel is a cosmic chess game, an infinite playing of “house,” like being let loose in a toy store. As a child I lived in a world of worlds, of fantasy places and people. Posing and peopling a novel is just like that except that it has to communicate and have at least a modicum of coherence. Treasure Island is great for seeing how the author works. Its bones show, but not in a way that distracts. It’s just plainly written and straightforward.

Thursday, December 22, 2011

Old Yeller, by Fred Gipson

Old Yeller, by Fred Gipson, is the source of the classic tear-jerker movie of the same name. And it’s a good book, even though I was guarding myself all the way through so I wouldn’t have a breakdown at the end. I liked the authentic portrayal of pioneer life in Texas—dangers and delights. The lead character, Travis, is left with his mom and little brother while his dad goes off on a cattle drive. His jobs on the farm at the edge of the frontier are fraught with danger and drama—and rightly so. He had to round up the hogs for cutting (marking) and castration without getting attacked by the deadly adult pigs. He has to hunt for food for the family. And he needs a dog. Along comes rascally Old Yeller (Old Marigold?). Travis and Old Yeller have a hate/love relationship until Yeller proves his great value.

Marigold, Mountain Cur
I have a special interest in this book because of my dog Marigold. I was told that her breed is mountain cur--a dog bred to suit the needs of small farmers and settlers in rugged terrain. Old Yeller was also a mountain cur, according to the breed's afficianados (although he was played by a yellow lab in the movie--for shame). I can testify on the intelligence and loyalty of Marigold, which makes Old Yeller's story entirely believable.

Any person who really gets to know a dog--any dog--will have marvelous tales to tell--not maybe of deadly contests with wild animals, but still tales of the dog's sensitivity and skill. Marigold has a special strategy for catching baby bunnies. (Rabbits are plentiful in my area, so don't go all weepy on me!) She will lay down (sphinx-like) a few feet from the hole and go still as stone. Over the next few minutes she will creep forward an inch or so at a time until she is frozen over the hole like an innocuous rock. Then--pow!--all of her coiled and compressed energy flows out into a dive right into the center of the hole. Tiny rabbits fly out in all directions like a bunny explosion. Marigold is not greedy. She'll end up with just one bunny--enough for a snack. And, let me tell you about my old dog Candy and the field mice...just kidding.

Go to http://www.dogster.com/dog-breeds/Mountain_Cur for more information on this breed. The site http://www.dogbreedinfo.com/mountaincur.htm describes the Old Yeller connection.

This movie still looks pretty authentic, but the dog is all
wrong--way too chunky and square-nosed to be the dog
described in the book.
Old Yeller is a tribute to great dogs, working dogs, partner dogs. Their courage and loyalty is unmatched in any species, I think. And their intelligence is greatly underestimated. The book's ending is heartbreaking, and is related to a looming threat introduced early in the book. Old Yeller is a fully developed character and his death is a supreme sacrificial moment--as important as any other sacrifice and not diminished because it was made by a dog. And as I so often observe, the presence of an animal can often ennoble us as humans. Travis's whole family is changed and strengthened because of their relationship to Old Yeller.

This is a good book. It holds up across time. The first-person narrative was great. The use of“frontier-speak” was light-handed, but enough to give Travis an authentic voice. Even people who don’t like dogs will identify with the friendship that develops between Yeller and Travis as they face great danger with great courage. All kids, I think, face great dangers and have great courage. This book is for them.